biography of Sir Peter Maxwell Davies© Martin Lengemann
updated December 12, 2016

Sir Peter Maxwell Davies

British composer born 8 September 1934 in Salford; died 14 March 2016 in Sanday (Orkney Islands).

Modernism, Tradition, Landscape, Community: The Musical World of Peter Maxwell Davies

by Jonathan Cross

Peter Maxwell Davies’s best known and most frequently performed work is his 1969 monodrama for baritone and ensemble, Eight Songs for a Mad King, which has become a classic of musical theater, in the tradition of Arnold Schoenberg’s Pierrot lunaire, op. 21, and Erwartung, op. 17. The work is a remarkable representation of the madness of George III, King of England in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. The vocal writing is extraordinary; Davies pushes the baritone to extremes, calling for extended vocal techniques that range from melody to raw noise and span the voice’s deepest lows to its highest reaches. The instrumental writing is just as striking; composed for six musicians, it follows the example of Pierrot lunaire but with an extra percussionist. Eight Songs is a kaleidoscope of quotation and parody, at times atonal, at times aleatoric. A flutist, imitating birdsong, plays from a giant onstage birdcage (which figures in the musical notation). One moment centers around the dramatic and moving destruction of a violin. The music represents the delirious mind of the mad king, who, toward the midpoint of the performance, sings in falsetto “Comfort Ye” from Handel’s Messiah (Handel was a contemporary of George III), accompanied by jazz-style piano. The ensemble metamorphizes into a foxtrot, then falls apart: yet another unsettling musical experience. In the context of the rapid societal changes occurring in the 1960s, the composition was a way for Davies to offer a welter of explicit critiques — of accepted ideas of social normality, of madness, of political power, and of religion, for example. In contrast with the more privileged upbringings and private educations of most English composers of his generation and before, Davies was the son of a laborer and educated in a public high school. As a homosexual, a polemicist, a republican, and an atheist — “angry young man” was a stance the Davies of the 1960s embraced.

The musical avant-gardes tended to move more slowly in the United Kingdom than elsewhere in Europe, and against that backdrop, Eight Songs was a decisive declaration of intention. More generally during those years, and in parallel with other major figures such as Luciano Berio, Hans Werner Henze, Mauricio Kagel, and György Ligeti, Davies helped to bring about the emergence of a new type of politicized musical theater. His own approach captured the expressive force of early twentieth-century Austro-German music and put it to work exploring the notion of treason — in particular the political and religious variety. This theme stands out in Revelation and Fall (1966), based on a text by Georg Trakl; in Missa super l'homme armé (1968); and in Vesalii Icones (1969) for dancer and ensemble.

Davies pursued similar themes in larger-scale settings. His first opera, Taverner (1970), whose libretto he also wrote, recounts episodes in the life of a sixteenth-century English composer, highlighting his conflicts with the Church in the context of the English Reformation. The central notion of the work is hypocrisy, and Davies’s hostility toward religion is again evident. As in his works of musical theater, the theme is expressed through quotation and parody. Indeed, the opera’s second act is a musical and dramatic parody of the first act, repackaged in a nightmarishly dark version of itself. One notable aspect of the work is the presence of Renaissance music, presented through pastiches of dances and fantasies of Taverner’s era, played on period instruments. Davies had been interested in fifteenth- and sixteenth-century music since his training in Manchester and then in Rome, where he studied with Goffredo Petrassi and encountered the masses of Palestrina and others sung in their liturgical setting. It was thus a natural next step to embrace the sixteenth-century genre of the parody mass: a mass composed from fragments of other, existing pieces of music. Similarly, Davies saw strong connections between the complex structures of Renaissance polyphony and the twelve-tone structures he studied at Princeton University with Milton Babbitt.

Several other operas stand out in his career. His chamber operas The Martyrdom of St. Magnus (1976) and The Lighthouse (1979) both deal with more intimate subjects, related to the people and the places that surrounded him in Scotland. His larger-scale operas continued to be polemical: Resurrection (1987) moved the themes and musical behaviors explored in Taverner into an entirely different dramatic context. Davies continued with these themes even toward the end of his life with Kommilitonen! (Young Blood!) (2011), which uses musical parody to critique ideologies and celebrate the triumph of the human spirit.

A very different facet of Davies’s creative identity can be seen in An Orkney Wedding, with Sunrise (1984), a delightful orchestral piece inspired by his life in the Scottish Orkneys, where he settled in the early 1970s. In this warm tribute to the people and traditions of the islands, the traditional Scottish dances of strathspeys and reels float through as if the music itself were tipsy. The piece culminates with the theatrical arrival of a bagpipe at the metaphorical moment of sunrise, bringing the wedding festivities to a close. The music is joyful and candid, with an elegance distinctly different from the fragmented surface of Eight Songs. For Davies, however, there was never any contradiction between his more complex, atonal, and avant-garde music and his more tonal, more direct music. As a composer, his attitude toward his materials, whether found or invented, changed very little: he was equally at home transforming eighteenth-century music as he was altering folk music to transmit a sense of place with powerful expressiveness.

Association with place was a constant in Davies’s output. Even when composing for symphony or string quartet, he never thought of the music as abstract: he often described his symphonies, for example, by referring to the landscapes of places he had lived. After meeting the Orcadian poet George Mackay Brown, he composed numerous works inspired by the folktales, traditions, and people of Northern Scotland. His first piece composed for one of Brown’s texts was From Stone to Thorn (1971), for soprano, basset clarinet, harpsichord, guitar, and percussion. Quite a contrast from his shouting and declaiming theater work of the 1960s, the song opened up a new expressive world for Davies. According to Paul Griffiths, it was the first time that he had interpreted a text unironically. Into the Labyrinth (1983) is a gentle, reverent interpretation of Brown’s words for tenor and ensemble, which examines the changes caused as modern technology arrived in the traditional lives of the Orkney Islanders. Also inspired by Brown’s writing is The Beltane Fire (1995). Originally intended as a ballet score, it ended up as an imagined “choreographic poem” for orchestra. This time, however, Davies approached Brown’s writing with music that is strong, rhythmic, and often violent. The result is a sort of Celtic Rite of Spring, a modern commentary on ancient traditions in the vein of Igor Stravinsky’s treatment of folk sources in Le Sacre du Printemps.

In choosing to evoke place, Davies also embraced a commitment to working with amateur and young musicians. From the 1960s onward, he wrote many pieces for children, though this music is not simplistic or “childish.” It was composed with the same artistic rigor as music for professional musicians, but is a little bit easier to play. His opera Cinderella (1979) is a good example. Written in the tradition of the English pantomime, it tells the familiar story of Cinderella, transposed to the twentieth century, with all the roles and musical parts (recorder, percussion, stringed instruments, trumpet, and piano) written for children. Here, again, Davies’s score refers to a variety of music, including Scottish reels and disco, this time not for the purposes of polemic parody but in order to capture the children’s attention and make them laugh.

In this way, he positioned himself in the English tradition of the community composer — personified before him by Benjamin Britten and his children’s work Noye’s Fludde (1958) — and he maintained this type of lively engagement until the end of his life. Among his last works is The Hogboon (2015), his dramatic opus for adult and children’s choirs and professional orchestra, adapted from an Orcadian folktale. Magnus, the seventh son of a seventh son, saves his community from an enormous monster, the “Nuckleavee,” by singing and dancing in a kind of reinterpretation of Monteverdi’s Orpheus. The community’s harmony is symbolized by a glorious D-major tonality, in keeping with its traditional employment to represent triumph.

Davies’s ten symphonies constitute the aesthetic backbone of his career. This may seem an unexpected about-face for a composer who in his youth cultivated the reputation of an enfant terrible struggling against the traditions and institutions of classical music culture. In reality, though, Davies was immersed in the classical tradition. It runs like a watermark through his works, which are full of ready references to Bach, Haydn, and Beethoven. In his early years, studying in Manchester, he read Heinrich Schenker’s treatise Der freie Satz (Free Composition), notably for its analyses of Beethoven’s Fifth and Ninth Symphonies, and during the preparatory work for Taverner he became aware of the need for “long-term thinking over a long span of time.” Recall, too, that Davies chose to study with Petrassi, who never himself adopted the twelve-tone technique but who did not discourage his student from using it as he worked on Prolation for orchestra, a major serial work composed in the shadow of Pierre Boulez and Luigi Nono. Petrassi himself also worked in dialogue with the musical past in a neoclassical, neo-Baroque style that bears the imprint of Stravinsky and Paul Hindemith. It is therefore not tremendously surprising that Davies embarked on a large-scale project for symphony orchestra soon after he completed Taverner and his forty-minute symphonic meditation Worldes Blis (1966-1969). (This stylistic evolution also coincided with his move to Scotland, which underlay an even broader questioning.)

Beethoven’s influence stands out in the structure of Symphony No. 1 (begun in 1973, completed in 1976, premiered in London in 1978), just as the “long-term approach” of Sibelius is salient in Symphony No. 5 (1994). Both composers were equally important to Davies’s work, and his challenge lay finding how to reinterpret the typically nineteenth-century symphonic genre to fit the late twentieth. The brilliant horn calls and long lines for violin that begin Symphony No. 1 evoke Beethoven as well as the landscape of the Orkney Islands, with seagulls calling and wheeling over high cliffs. Punctuated by the mystical or ritual sound of rattles, the music builds around “centers”: moments of repose or focus that function as tonal centers did in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, within an architecture that maintains only a distant relationship to tonality. Symphony No. 5 packages symphonic form within a single movement. Triads appear stripped of tonal connotation. Quasi-Sibelian development occurs in waves, manifesting as a musical and metaphorical voyage.

Davies’s final symphony, No. 10, for baritone, choir, and large orchestra, premiered in London in 2014 and has a more melancholy, nostalgic feel, as if looking back over the musical worlds of Gustav Mahler and Alban Berg. Composed as Davies was battling cancer, the music has a distinct vulnerability, a fragility to it. He would pass away two years later. Titled “Alla ricerca di Borromini,” the symphony explores the life and death of Francesco Borromini, a seventeenth-century Roman architect. This was not the first time Davies had composed a work inspired by Borromini: the movements of Naxos Quartet No. 7, are named for buildings he designed. Similarly, Symphony No. 3 pays tribute to Filippo Brunelleschi. Davies’s explorations of architecture thus extend well beyond Beethoven and Sibelius to Baroque monuments of Rome. Music’s large-scale structure remained a central concern to him until the end of his life — but in service of expression.

Despite successive stylistic changes lapping over the surface of Davies’s music — his dazzling response to the complexity he found in the world — a common thread runs through his works: interpretation of the distant past, notably music of the Middle Ages and Renaissance. Many of his works wind into Gregorian chant. For example, Griffiths describes Alma Redemptoris Mater (1957) as a parody of a parody; specifically, Davies based it on a John Dunstable motet that itself was based on a chant. Another example is Ave Maris Stella (1975), one of the first major pieces he wrote in Scotland (and, as such, a transitional work), where his use of the eponymous chant (describing the Virgin as “star of the sea”) pays tribute to the sea surrounding the Orkneys. Ave maris stella is the source of the piece’s harmony, melody, and rhythms; it is transformed serially into a network of pitches and values, “projected through the magic Square of the Moon,” Davies specified. A parallel process is at work in A Mirror of Whitening Light (1976-1977), applied to the chant Veni sancte spiritus. A hidden Gregorian chant also underlies the structure of the Symphony No. 5.

Similar to Schoenberg, similar to Anton Webern, similar to Stravinsky, Davies looked for ways to tie the present to the historical past — even as he recognized the violence of the rupture between the two. As a whole, his music speaks to us of modernity, in its own highly personal way.

From the expressionist anger of the 1960s to the softer, more tonal pieces he wrote to celebrate the inhabitants of the Orkney Islands, Davies’s music has tremendous breadth. Although he may speak with multiple voices, the themes and questions he explored belong to a coherent whole. He fought hypocrisy and injustice; he saw the composer as embedded in community, a coordinator and a spokesperson; he found his unique approach to musical structure; he maintained a creative and critical stance toward musical history; and he embraced joy and humor.

Peter Maxwell Davies’s contribution to the growth of British music in the late twentieth century is incontestable. Along with his contemporaries and close friends Harrison Birtwistle and Alexander Goehr, he brought avant-garde ideas into a country hitherto skeptical of strong modernism. Against the backdrop of the 1960s, with its social revolutions and the upheavals transforming British popular music from the Beatles to the Rolling Stones, Davies brought a similarly revolutionary — and international — perspective to classical music. He showed that it was possible to adopt music derived from Schoenberg of the 1920s and Babbitt, Boulez, and Nono of the 1950s in a way that preserves a British and even a Scottish flair — a sense of belonging to one’s own traditions and place. This is how his legacy fits into the long tradition of European music of the centuries past.

Text translated from the French by Miranda Richmond-Mouillot
© Ircam-Centre Pompidou, 2016


Do you notice a mistake?

IRCAM Multimedia Library

1, place Igor-Stravinsky
75004 Paris
+33 1 44 78 47 44

opening times

From Tuesday to Friday, from 2.00 pm to 5.30 pm

subway access

Hôtel de Ville, Rambuteau, Châtelet, Les Halles

Institut de Recherche et de Coordination Acoustique/Musique

Copyright © 2022 Ircam. All rights reserved.