informations

Type
Séminaire / Conférence
durée
28 min
date
8 octobre 2015
note de programme
TCPM 2015

The analysis of creative process in music through written sources intertwines often with hermeneutics [Kinderman 2009], in a way not dissimilar from philological studies, whose basic purpose ―although many attempts to delimit or to unbind it― remains ‘making sense of texts’ [Pollock 2009: 934]. An interesting field for music philology in order to investigate the ways a musical text took form seems to be the study of musical texts transcribing unwritten music, since they, facing music notation with music conceived out of a notation system, allow to explore the rationale underpinning the choices made by the transcriber, whose act encloses undoubtedly a creative activity [Arom 2002; Nettl 2005; Scaldaferri 2005].
A significant case study for this kind of enquiry in “music transcription philology” could be that of Alberto Favara (18631923), who is considered the first scholar approaching the Sicilian folk music not only through the transcription of the melodies and/or their texts but also through the study of the multiverse whereof they were part and expression [Leydi 1996: 26]. Born in Salemi, near Trapani (Sicily), and trained as composer, Favara had a multifaceted personality: composer, teacher for composition and sing, speech therapist, musicologist, music critic, concert manager, and proto-ethnomusicologist. He became interested in Sicilian folk music after being appointed as professor for composition at Palermo Conservatory, having already composed two operas, cantatas, and symphonic works. Between 1898 and 1905 he collected more than one thousand folk songs, travelling at his own expenses through Sicily and coming in contact with cultural fields far away from his milieu, both in urban and in non-urban contexts.
Although he was not able to raise funds for publishing the song collection, he presented part of his work, both as musicological essasys, appeared between 1898 and 1905 [Favara 1959]], and as compositions for voice and piano based on the transcription of the collected material [Favara 1907, 1921]. It is interesting to note that he was perfectly aware of his creative approach to Sicilian folk music, as in his essays he declares that this ‘natural’ music could allow a basic regeneration of Italian national music. Clearly influenced from Nietzschean philosophy ―as the references to Friedrich Nietzsche’s The Birth of Tragedy in his essays testifies―, he was interested in the search for ancient Greek roots as statement of and means for a music founded on interaction of gesture, voice and melos as expression of natural forces effecting on the singing body embedded in the world.
The songs were first transcribed in modern Western musical notation but without segmentation through bars and without accompaniment (in this form were edited only posthumously by Ottavio Tiby [Favara 1957]). On the basis of this transcriptions Favara achieved the artistic transcriptions for voice and piano, in which he realised the desired rekindling of Italian music.
The published sources display a broad range of creative acts that can be systematized in three main groups:

  1. Analytical transcription. The monodic transcription is both descriptive and prescriptive, as it sets some paramters for pitch and rhythm in order to make the songs analyzable and mental performable by people trained in Western music notation but without any knowledge of Sicilian folk songs. The degree of accuracy in transcriptions oscillates between emic and etic: while the rhythm is not fixed in isochronic metrical structures, thus reproducing the performance state of the transcribed songs, the pitch is put in a sort of preset modal system, being the songs transcribed not in their absolute pitch but in abstract scalar systems mostly rooted on D, E, and F, thus reflecting the (asserted) idea of their connection with “Greek modes” (respectively the Dorian, the Phryigian, and the Lydian) as categorized during 19th-Century [Powers 1992].
  2. Thick evocations. In his essays, Favara not only explains his purposes, his conceptual sources, and the results of his analysis, but he also describes in highly evocative terms the conditions of performances and his role in transcribing the songs, recognizing his being-in-the-performance as source of artistic inspiration.
  3. Artistic transcription. In spite of their “modalized” analytical transcription the folk songs in the version for voice and piano are less harmonized through the modal harmony, typical of the the coeval harmonization of plain chant and folk music [Gonnard 2000: 91 150; Gelbart 2011: 111151], than through the irrelation of the syntax of tonal harmony, with some effects of pitched percussions. The rhythmic fluidity of the songs, despite the use of isochronism and bars, is mantained by means of meter changes.
    The aim of my paper is to examine on the basis of the conceptual interacting written sources how a Western trained composer of late 19th-Century reacted to Sicilian folk songs. Both kinds of transcriptions reveal how the creative process through which Favara intended to renew the Italian music was centred on a tension between different ways to conceive and organize melody. On the one hand there is a melody structured on pitches embedded in a harmonic system ordered through leading tones and a simple double modal organization, on the other hand there is a melos structured around voiced tones generating melodic types and a multi-modal system. The collision between this two structuring principles caused a sort of “scalar normalization” in the analytical transcription and enabled the emancipation of syntax of tonal harmony from its teleological organization in the song collection for piano and voice, allowing a free motion of tonal harmony-chords on the basis of a complex modal melos.

intervenants

Les médias liés à cet évènement

Metaphors of Creative Practice: Navigating Roots and Foliage in Southern Vietnamese Traditional Music - Alexander Cannon

Traditional music in southern Vietnam does not sit idly on the sidelines of cosmopolitanism, globalization, and modernity. Musicians travel from Long Xuyên to Hồ Chí Minh City and then fly to Bangkok, Dubai, and Seattle, interacting with a

8 octobre 2015 27 min

Vidéo

Jesper Nordin’s Sculpting the Air (2014-5): An Experiment in Technologically-Augmented Orchestra Conducting - Baptiste Bacot, François-Xavier Féron

8 octobre 2015 33 min

Vidéo

Investigating performative approaches through the analysis of ‘Performing Scores’: Cathy Berberian sings Circles - Giovanni Cestino

In the rich landscape of studies about performance as a creative process, the investigation of such preliminary phases that go before the performance itself (i.e. the study process or the rehearsal practice) presented themselves like a more

8 octobre 2015 30 min

Vidéo

Versions, Variants, and the performatives of the score: Traces of performances in the texts of Anton Webern’s Music - Thomas Ahrend

Most research on the creative process of Anton Webern’s music has focused on the sketches, thus emphasizing the compositional process in the narrower sense. Less attention has been paid to the fact that especially for most of the works comp

8 octobre 2015 31 min

Vidéo

Ligeti and Romanian folklore: Citation, palimpsest and pastiche as creative tools - Bianca Temes

The paper aims to gain fresh perspectives and to challenge standard thinking on Ligeti’s appropriation of Romanian folk music, drawing on very recent findings at the Sacher archives. By absorbing Romanian folk music in various ways during t

8 octobre 2015 24 min

Vidéo

The genesis of Beethoven’s Piano Sonata Op. 101: ‘Lost sketches’ and ‘Working autograph’ - Federica Rovelli

The researcher who desires to reconstruct the genesis of a particular work of Beethoven often bumps into the problem of the lack of correspondent sketches or drafts. Several examples – such as the op. 27, no. 2 piano sonata (first and secon

8 octobre 2015 30 min

Vidéo

Créativité et design sonore : étude de cas - Andrea Cera, Sébastien Gaxie, Nicolas Misdariis

Le design sonore est un champ du design relativement récent qui consiste principalement à prendre en compte la dimension sonore d’un objet au cours de son processus de conception – le terme objet pouvant être pris au sens d’objet tangibl

8 octobre 2015 29 min

Vidéo

Introduction (FR) - Nicolas Donin, Hyacinthe Ravet, Jean-François Trubert

8 octobre 2015 14 min

Vidéo

Creativity and Sound Design: A Case Study - Andrea Cera, Sébastien Gaxie, Nicolas Misdariis

8 octobre 2015 29 min

Vidéo

Performer’s Gesture and Compositional Process in Xenakis’ Solo Pieces - Anne-Sylvie Barthel-Calvet

Simultaneous translation: Marie-Louise Diomède

8 octobre 2015 28 min

Vidéo

La place du geste de l’interprète dans le processus compositionnel : le cas des œuvres solistiques de Xenakis - Anne-Sylvie Barthel-Calvet

Dans cette communication, je me propose de croiser deux problématiques, celle des relations compositeur-interprète dans le processus compositionnel, relations dans lesquelles le positionnement de Xenakis s’avère assez particulier par rappor

8 octobre 2015 28 min

Vidéo

Sculpting the Air (2014-15) de Jesper Nordin : l’expérimentation d’une direction d’orchestre techno-augmentée - Baptiste Bacot, François-Xavier Féron

Exformation Trilogy est un cycle de trois pièces mixtes que le compositeur suédois Jesper Nordin projette de composer entre 2014 et 2017 en utilisant Gestrument, une interface de contrôle gestuel qu’il a lui-même développée. Sculpting the A

8 octobre 2015 33 min

Vidéo

Opening address (EN) - Nicolas Donin, Hyacinthe Ravet, Jean-François Trubert

Simultaneous translation: Marie-Louise Diomède

8 octobre 2015 14 min

Vidéo

Sounding Bodies: Embodiment and Gesture in the Collaborative Creation and Realisation of works for Piano and Electronics - Zubin Kanga

This paper examines works for piano and electronics that use technology to expand and subvert the body and pianistic technique of the pianist. It draws upon the fledgling research field of auto-ethnographic examination of composer-performer

8 octobre 2015 28 min

Vidéo

No score, hundreds of sketches: Mario Bertoncini’s Spazio-Tempo - Valentina Bertolani

In the last decades, sketch studies and musical philology have been expanding their object of study to include non-conventional notation and alternative supports for the diffusion of the work of art, such as tapes or pieces of code (e. g. H

8 octobre 2015 25 min

Vidéo

Creativity within Formal Structures: Two American Indian Song Repertories - Tara Browner

In traditional First Nations musical expression, the formal structures of music often hold both spiritual and political meanings beyond the songs themselves. As frameworks for composition most often referred to as “song making” these forms

8 octobre 2015 29 min

Vidéo

La pratique de la direction d’orchestre au prisme du genre - Claire Gibault, Dominique My, Hyacinthe Ravet

8 octobre 2015 01 h 48 min

Vidéo

'Feeling New Strength': Beethoven's Ninth Symphony and Quartet in A Minor, Op. 132 - William Kinderman

One landmark in the reception history of Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony is Thomas Mann’s novel Doktor Faustus, in which Mann places his fictional composer Adrian Leverkühn into the role of the Faustian figure. Leverkühn’s culminating work is

8 octobre 2015 29 min

Vidéo

Gender and the Practice of Conducting

On the occasion of the publication of "L’orchestre au travail. Interactions, négociations, coopérations" (Ravet, 2015) which is based on the observation of several conductors and several ensembles in the process of constructing a musical pe

8 octobre 2015 01 h 49 min

Vidéo

What is it to analyse the creative process in music? - Georgina Born

8 octobre 2015 01 h 12 min

Vidéo

Qu’est-ce qu’analyser les processus de création musicale ? - Georgina Born

Traduction simultanée : Marie-Louise Diomède

8 octobre 2015 01 h 12 min

Vidéo

partager


Vous constatez une erreur ?

IRCAM

1, place Igor-Stravinsky
75004 Paris
+33 1 44 78 48 43

heures d'ouverture

Du lundi au vendredi de 9h30 à 19h
Fermé le samedi et le dimanche

accès en transports

Hôtel de Ville, Rambuteau, Châtelet, Les Halles

Institut de Recherche et de Coordination Acoustique/Musique

Copyright © 2022 Ircam. All rights reserved.